I Play Rocky: Old Underdog, New Tricks

Posted
Anthony Ippolito as Sylvester Stallone and Stephen James as Carl Weathers in I Play Rocky

I spotted a fun cinephile Easter egg in I Play Rocky, director Peter Farrelly’s predictable (duh) but breezy and disarming making-of about the 1976 Best Picture winner that transformed a 30-year-old Sylvester Stallone from an unknown to a superstar overnight. 

In I Play’s early moments, when Sly is a starving actor in New York City going by “Mike” instead of his mouthful of a government name, he gets a job at a movie theater. There he meets a nice girl named Sasha (AnnaSophia Robb), who, in the space of an 18-month fast-forward to when they’re living together in Los Angeles, will become his wife. He wins her over not with his burly frame, but with his nascent film-bro brio, offering a thoughtful critique of one of the movies playing at their workplace—Francis Ford Coppola’s paranoid classic The Conversation, no less. But one of the other revered ’70s documents on the marquee is Robert Altman’s The Long Goodbye, which, among its other virtues, includes an impossible-to-miss cameo by 25-year-old Arnold Schwarzenegger in a nonspeaking role. The two biggest action stars of the ‘roided-out Reagan ’80s got their showbiz start in the sensitive, movies-are-for-grown-ups ’70s.

Anthony Ippolito stars as Sylvester Stallone in I Play Rocky, from Amazon MGM Studios. Photo credit: Claire Folger © 2026 Amazon Content Services LLC. All Rights Reserved.

Indeed, I Play Rocky is determined to blast away the bombast and hokum that attached itself to the franchise as its sequels wore on, and remind us that Rocky was a slow-moving mumblecore character piece about an over-the-hill palooka who finds an unlikely way to establish his self-worth. When most people think of Rocky, what they’re really thinking of are the sequels, where the training montages multiply and our man Rocko actually wins the big match. The fact that he doesn’t is the grace note that made Stallone’s script for Rocky unique enough that producers Irwin Winkler and Robert Chartoff were eager to buy it from the novice scribe. Stallone, who was so broke at the time he had to sell his dog for $40 (an oft-told anecdote that I Play Rocky screenwriter Peter Gamble, being no fool, has included), declined every offer that did not include him playing the title part—never mind that one of the handful of movie roles on his resume was in a porno film. 

As Stallone, Anthony Ippolito achieves an astonishing physical and vocal approximation of the Italian Stallion circa 50 years ago. If Robert Pattinson wasn’t even trying to look or sound like Chris Hansen in Primetime, Ippolito embodies the opposite approach to portraying a widely recognized public figure. Toby Kebbell and P.J. Byrne nave an easier time as Chartoff and Winkler, the producers who eventually risk their own relationship with United Artists (and their homes, once Rocky runs over budget) to get the movie made over the objections of Sandy Maddox, a composite character representing various naysayers who were desperate to replace the mumbly, unproven “Sylvester Spillane” (as Sandy calls him at one point) with a real star like Burt Reynolds or Ryan O’Neal. As Sandy, Tracy Letts brings a comic tartness that prevents I Play Rocky’s genial optimism from ever becoming too saccharine to endure.

Stephan James as Carl Weathers and Anthony Ippolito as Sylvester Stallone in I Play Rocky, from Amazon MGM Studios. Photo credit: Claire Folger © 2026 Amazon Content Services LLC. All Rights Reserved.

The third triumphant piece of casting here is that of Stephan James as Carl Weathers, the athlete turned actor who won the role of flamboyant heavyweight champion Apollo Creed after plans to cast a real boxer like Joe Frazier or Ken Norton came to naught. James, who played Olympian Jesse Owens in Race and a wrongfully imprisoned man in Barry Jenkins’ If Beale Street Could Talk, is the ideal vessel for Weathers’ beauty, bravado, and good humor.

As John G. Avlidsen, the flinty director Chartoff and Winkler hired to get their film done on the impossibly tight budget and impossibly short schedule afforded them, Jay Duplass has been cast—himself an indie filmmaker who counts Rocky as his favorite film. As Duplass told an audience at the Middleburg Film Festival last month, he called Farrelly and lobbied for the part. To see I Play Rocky is to understand why: It’s a necessarily episodic chronicle of the many logistical, temperamental, and human obstacles Rocky had to clear to become the phenomenon that it did. 

I Play Rocky (PG-13, 128 mins.) opens today, Nov. 13.

Arts, Film/TV, film review