A Texas appeals court has thrown out a lawsuit brought against Houston ISD and Superintendent Mike Miles over teacher’s state-funded pay raises.
The lawsuit, brought against the district by the Houston Federation of Teachers, sought to force the district to use state funds allocated to a new Teacher Retention Allotment, an allotment created when the Texas Legislature passed House Bill 2, for the intended purpose to provide across-the-board pay raises for classroom teachers with at least three years of experience in the district.
The standard of the law in districts with more than 5,000 students was to provide a $2,500 increase for classroom teachers with 3-5 years of teaching experience and a $5,000 increase for classroom teachers with five or more years of experience.
HFT argued that HISD was required to distribute the raises according to the model outlined in the law. However, the union alleged that Miles and the district’s appointed board instead adopted a 2025-26 budget that directed TRA funds toward incentive-based pay.
The Texas First Court of Appeals dismissed the lawsuit Tuesday, vacating a temporary injunction in the case.
In a statement, HFT said the court’s decision was procedural and did not determine whether HISD complied with the law.
“Neither the trial court nor the Court of Appeals ruled on the merits of the dispute,” the union said. “The Court held that HFT must submit the dispute to HISD’s internal grievance process. If HISD denies the grievance, the dispute can be appealed to the Commissioner of Education.”
Brad Wray, an executive board member with HFT, also emphasized that the underlying dispute remains unresolved.
“Yesterday, the appeals court vacated the temporary injunction and dismissed the lawsuit, concluding that HFT was required to exhaust its administrative remedies through the Texas Education Agency before pursuing the case in court. That distinction is important. The court did not decide whether HISD’s compensation plan ultimately complied with the Teacher Retention Allotment law. The underlying dispute over how HISD handled the state funding intended to support teacher compensation remains unresolved,” Wray said.
HFT President Jackie Anderson criticized the district’s approach to the funding, saying the allotment was intended to provide financial relief to educators.
“Mike Miles decided to play games with educators’ livelihoods at a time when they and their families need relief the most. The rising cost of living is burying working families, and Texas still faces an educator shortage. That’s what the Teacher Retention Allotment was painstakingly crafted to address,” Anderson said.
Anderson said the union filed the lawsuit to prevent the district from using its share of the allotment in a way HFT believes violates the law.
“We filed this lawsuit to stop the district from burning through their share of the allotment in violation of the law, and in that respect we were successful. Now the real work begins to collaborate with elected district leaders and win teachers the money they should have received over a year ago,” she said.
Wray called the dismissal a setback but said the union’s efforts to secure the raises would continue.
“We cannot allow this setback to become an excuse for inaction. We cannot allow frustration to turn into resignation. And we cannot allow those who would prefer educators to remain silent and powerless to have the last word,” Wray said.
HFT also pointed to Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa’s public pledge to end state takeovers in districts such as Houston ISD. The union said Texas AFT and HFT will continue advocating for compliance with HB 2 and the teacher raises once a democratically elected school board regains authority.
The union’s next step is to pursue the district’s internal grievance process, with the possibility of appealing to the Texas Education Commissioner if the grievance is denied.
KPRC 2 has reached out to Houston ISD for a statement.